Growth changes everything for law firms—more cases, bigger stakes, tighter margins. Pairing with a private investigator can supercharge your wins, but the bill can sting. In New York’s legal jungle, where fraud and litigation run hot, can you negotiate rates with a PI that keep your firm lean and let them thrive too? After they’ve cracked a case—like exposing a fraudulent insurance claim that saved your client millions—there’s room to talk.

Here’s how it can work:

  1. Prove Value First: A PI who’s delivered—like incriminating footage of a “disabled” claimant working on his home or playing basketball at the park—earns leverage. Results open the rate discussion.  If you feel that the PI is worth their salt, then come to an agreement.  Don’t forget the old adage, “You get what you pay for!”.
  2. Tiered Rates: Low fees for quick checks (e.g., backgrounds), premium for deep dives (e.g., financial tracing). Again, let the PI prove their worth.  A good PI will be worth their weight in gold.
  3. Leverage Growth: Your expanding caseload means steady work for them—use it to balance costs without squeezing quality.

From TrueBlue Consulting, LLC’s lens in New York, the real payoff is mutual momentum. Our evidence lands a firm a headline win—like a multi-party fraud case—they snag bigger clients. We get referrals, stretching our reach. It’s harmony, not haggling: they tackle tougher cases, we sharpen our edge. Some firms push too hard on rates and sour it, though. What’s your view? Can law firms and PIs grow together without it feeling like a trade-off? How do you balance cost and partnership?

Categories